Escape to Oregon’s Pioneer Days

Escape to Oregon’s Pioneer Days

by | Aug 23, 2024 | Book review, Historical novels, Medical History, Oregon Territory, Women's Struggles

Greetings, Reading Friend! 

I hope you’ve had a chance for a break during this warm season (in the northern hemisphere). I’ve enjoyed time with family and friends in my native Pacific Northwest.

Returning to my Northwest roots, I discovered a novel set in that region, All She Left Behind, and I review it below.

When I’m not reading other authors’ novels, I’m revising Lucia’s Journey, my new novel, based on feedback from my beta-readers.  (Thank you so much to each one!). I hope to publish it in the next few months.

My Review of All She Left Behind, by Jane Kirkpatrick

All She Left Behind, by Jane Kirkpatrick, cover image

How could a girl who struggled with reading and spelling, born into a pioneer family settled in the Oregon Territory, become a medical doctor?

Jennie Lichtenthaler’s passion to be a healer seemed an impossible dream, and she received little encouragement to pursue a life beyond the traditional role of wife and mother.

Yet All She Left Behind, a historical novel, tells the surprising, fact-based story of Jennie’s life. Readers may think its twists and turns couldn’t possibly reflect reality, but its skillful author, Jane Kirkpatrick, has crafted this captivating novel using information gleaned from historical documents.

Kirkpatrick shows the obstacles Jennie faced, including:

  • The attitudes of close family members
  • Society’s reluctance to allow female physicians.

The author also reveals how dreams delayed were not always dreams destroyed in Jennie’s life.

 

Characters:

They are both historical and fictional, distinctive, some even memorable.

 Because Jennie’s life story includes many characters, I list only those who play major roles in the novel:

 Jennie Lichtenthaler—protagonist; young pioneer woman married at 17; her circumstances thwart her ambition to become a physician

 Josiah Parrish—Jennie’s second husband, a blacksmith, sheep breeder, and missionary who encourages Jennie’s medical studies and career

 Elizabeth Parrish—Josiah’s first wife; Jennie takes care of her in Elizabeth’s declining days

 Charles Pickett—Jennie’s first husband, he can’t overcome his addictions to alcohol and drugs

 Douglas Pickett—son of Jennie and Charles, he struggles with addictions

 Ariyah Cole—Jennie’s fictional best friend, an artist who provides a sounding board and support for Jennie

 Priscilla Melvin—a prostitute whose life takes a new turn; Jennie’s encounters with her near the beginning and ending of Jennie’s adult life reveal her character arc.

 Callie Charlton—Jennie’s fellow female medical student and colleague

 

Strengths:

  • Inspiring story
  • Well-developed characters
  • Setting details transport readers into the Oregon Territory and early days of statehood in the last half of the 1800s
  • This novel reveals the state of the medical profession and the status of women in that era.

Weakness:

 The prologue seemed a bit confusing to place in the context of the chapters that follow.

 

Content review:

 This novel discusses struggles with and details of addiction to alcohol, drugs, and sex.

 

My recommendation:

 All She Left Behind will appeal to readers who appreciate a lively plot that Includes historical as well as romantic and inspirational elements. As a native of the Pacific Northwest, I enjoyed the window this novel provided into the history of Oregon in the early days of statehood.

 

Reader, can you recommend a novel set in the Northwest?

It’s 1865: What’s a Woman to Do?

It’s 1865: What’s a Woman to Do?

by | Oct 8, 2022 | Book review, Historical novels, Medical History, U.S. Civil War, Women's Struggles

Suppose you nurtured a passion for your future and studied for years to prepare for it, only to have your father veto your choice!

What would you do?

In 1865, Vita, the teen daughter of a Massachusetts physician, dreams of following in her father’s footsteps, but he adamantly opposes her plan because of her gender.

The Physician’s Daughter, by Martha Conway, skillfully navigates this drama and the creative ways Vita pursues her ambition in an era when women have limited control over their destinies.

The Physician's Daughter, by Martha Conway, cover image

After Vita learns of women who have succeeded in becoming physicians, she devotes herself to joining their ranks.

In addition to external challenges, she confronts self-doubt as she realizes her ability to memorize medical facts is only one element in the skillset of a successful physician.

Vita must also deal with her family’s expectations that she will marry and settle into a traditional lifestyle. Her plan to marry but still pursue a career in medicine runs into problems, and the story reveals how she deals with them.

Characters:

  • Vita, the protagonist – elicits my sympathy for her plight and her smarts, even if her emotional intelligence develops slowly.
  • Jacob – a damaged veteran of the Civil War, he’s an interesting blend of old-fashioned and modern ideas (for his era), which makes him a challenge for Vita to understand.
  • Mitty – Vita’s mother, wife of Dar – I sympathized with her position in life, but I found her lacking as a support for Vita’s aspirations
  • Dar/ Dr. Tenney – Vita’s father, an old-school physician, dubious of women’s capabilities, he’s deeply affected by his son’s death near the end of the Civil War. When Vita brings up her desire to attend medical school, he responds with, “You think you can replace your brother? You hope to profit from our loss, like a turkey vulture? No one can take the place of my son.”
  • Freddy – Vita’s beloved brother, he dies at the end of the Civil War
  • Amelia – Vita’s younger sister, she’s very traditional and doesn’t support Vita’s dreams.

Strengths:

The Physician’s Daughter is an engaging portrait of life and women’s struggles in the Civil War era.

Weakness:

The portrayal of Dr. Tenney, Vita’s father, showed no sympathy for Vita; even before his son’s death, he never showed humanity or love toward Vita.

Content review:

The Physician’s Daughter includes descriptions of war wounds and intimacy within marriage.

If you enjoy reading about the Civil War era and how women in bygone times have struggled to overcome discrimination, this novel will inspire and appeal to you.

Reader, what novels about women have inspired you?