Mystery and Music in Prague

Mystery and Music in Prague

Greetings, Reading Friend!

Prague is the topic for this month, with my review of Prague Sonata, a novel I had the privilege of reading while visiting Prague recently for the first time.

While I admired the picturesque, spire-filled city, its millennium of history impressed on me the suffering of so many in Prague—especially in the Jewish quarter, ravaged by persecution for many centuries, and the execution of Jan Hus for daring to defy the Church by expressing religious ideas.

Prague Sonata, by Bradford Morrow, cover image

Imagine you’re a young musicologist, who at a friend’s urging meets with an ageing holocaust survivor.

How could this brief encounter possibly change the course of your life?

And how could the hunt for missing musical manuscripts from three centuries ago drastically alter multiple people’s lives in the twenty-first century?

Prague Sonata, a musical mystery and historical novel, spans two continents and more than three centuries to answer these questions and more, while taking readers on a suspenseful ride.

Irena, aware that her life will soon end, gives Meta, a young musicology graduate student, an original manuscript of the middle movement of a sonata whose composer is unknown.

Meta’s life changes immediately. She travels to Prague to search for the two missing movements of the sonata, but multiple frustrations impede her pursuit.

Prague Sonata’s themes include passion for music, love, and devotion to a quest. The novel also reveals how some characters compromise their idealism for survival and profit.

Characters:

Meta—the protagonist, musicology graduate student, and rising pianist whose injury ended her performing career

Otylie Bartosová—the sonata’s Czech owner who divided the sonata into thirds and distributed it

Jakub BartosOtylie’s husband, a Jewish antiquarian who joins the Resistance when the Nazis invade Czechoslovakia

Irena SvobodovaOtylie’s best friend in Prague; she plays an important role in the later plot

GillianMeta’s best friend; she introduces Meta to the musical mystery

Paul MandelbaumMeta’s graduate school mentor, whose interesting connections to Prague enrich the plot

Tomáspianist friend of Jakub who plays an important role in the plot

Gerrit Mills—Czech-American reporter, he becomes Meta’s romantic interest and research partner in Prague

Jaromir LáskaOtylie’s father, a poor music teacher who purchased the sonata from an antiquarian; he tells Meta to “guard it as if it were your own child”

Petr WittmanPrague musicologist and author who becomes Meta’s bête noire

JonathanGillian’s brother, a New York banker who is Meta’s romantic interest early in the novel

Strengths:

In addition to an engaging plot, the author portrays characters as multi-dimensional people, with strengths and weaknesses.

Weakness:

The novel’s length may lose some readers, although the length adds to the understanding of the personalities in multiple time periods.

Content review:

This novel contains several scenes of physical intimacy, which could have been omitted without weakening the plot.

My Recommendation:

As soon as I discovered that Prague Sonata features historical fiction involving music history, as well as an exciting plot, I was hooked.  Readers with similar interests, especially those who like stories transporting them to multiples locations and time periods will also enjoy this novel.

Reader, can you recommend a novel about Prague?

Between Crown and Chisel: The Princess Who Wouldn’t Yield Her Dream

Between Crown and Chisel: The Princess Who Wouldn’t Yield Her Dream

Imagine you’re from a wealthy English family, coming of age in the second half of the 1800s, an independent female thinker, a supporter of women’s rights, and a sculptor.

How could you live out your identity if you were Princess Louise, daughter of the domineering, grief-obsessed Queen Victoria?

In the Shadow of a Queen, by Heather B. Moore, cover image

Heather B. Moore answers this question in her recent historical novel, In the Shadow of a Queen, based on her research into the life of Princess Louise, the fourth daughter of Queen Victoria and Prince Albert.

The novel begins when Louise is twelve, includes her father’s death and many scenes of her interactions with family members and friends, revealing the unique personality of each individual. The author doesn’t shy away from conflicts, and she closes the story with Louise’s decision of what would be her life’s project.

 

Characters:

Princess Louise—fourth daughter and sixth child of Queen Victoria and Prince Albert, a talented sculptor and independent thinker who chafed at her mother’s off-the-cuff dictums

Queen Victoria—a forceful personality who bonded so strongly with her husband, Prince Albert, that she depended to an unhealthy degree on her daughters, changed her mind frequently, and never recovered from Albert’s death

John Campbell, Marquess of Lorne—Scottish suitor of Louise, a commoner considered after no attractive royal options materialized

Sybil Grey—Louise’s loyal friend, daughter of General Grey, the queen’s loyal aide

Albert Edward (Bertie), Prince of Wales—Victoria’s oldest son, heir to the throne; a sympathetic older brother to Louise as she grows up, despite his moral lapses

Louise’s other brothers: Alfred, Arthur, Leopold (Leo)

Louise’s sisters: Victoria (Vicky), Alice, Helena, Beatrice

Strengths:

In the Shadow of a Queen captures the personalities of each member of the Victorian English Royal Family, as well as others. In particular, the author shows the pressures Queen Victoria exerted on Princess Louise (and her other children), and how Louise dealt with them.

 

Weakness:

The story reads more like a biography than a novel, because indeed, it’s a lightly-fictionalized biography.

 

Content review:

This novel reveals the character weaknesses of the royal family, including smoking, class discrimination, and adultery (all common in the era).

 

My recommendation:

I found this novel entertaining and educational. If you enjoy books that neither romanticize nor scandalize the lives of royals, In the Shadow of a Queen will give you an opportunity to get to know Princess Louise and reflect on her life, dreams, and achievements.

 

Reader, can you suggest favorite novels about royal families?

From Persecution to Privilege: The Unlikely Journey of a Fille du Roi

From Persecution to Privilege: The Unlikely Journey of a Fille du Roi

What does it mean to risk everything for faith and freedom?

Kerry Chaput’s evocative novel, Daughter of the King, follows Isabelle Colette, a young Huguenot woman whose courage and convictions propel her from the shadows of persecution in France to the uncertain promise of New France.

Daughter of the King, by Kerry Chaput, cover image

Daughter of the King  

How could a heretic persecuted by the French king’s dragoons be chosen as a Fille du Roi (Daughter of the King) and given special privileges?

Daughter of the King tells the remarkable (fictionalized) story of Isabelle and her family, who could scarcely survive, let alone thrive, in La Rochelle in the last half of the 1600s. The novel exemplifies the fates of Protestants (known as Huguenots in France) during and after the Wars of Religion.

Throughout this novel, Isabelle must deal with many conflicts and decisions related to her religious faith, among them whether to:
• hide away at home to avoid persecution, as her mother counsels
• embrace a relationship with a sympathetic Catholic soldier
• betray her heritage and convert to Catholicism to gain a new life in New France

Chaput’s vivid characters and harrowing choices bring to life this little-known chapter of history, as Isabelle’s decisions lead to a life of adventure and an action-packed story.

Major Characters:

Isabelle Colette—protagonist, she’s a young Huguenot woman whose independent streak assists others and often endangers herself

James— Isabelle’s first love; he’s a young French soldier who, despite his Catholicism, rescues Isabelle from the dragoons

Andre—French fur trapper; his wild streak connects with Isabelle’s independence

Henri—Huguenot friend from Isabelle‘s youth in La Rochelle

Naira—young Native-American (Huron) woman with nearly incredible intuition and wisdom; she assists and bonds with Isabelle

Angelique—Isabelle’s mother; she’s a Huguenot who retreated to her home, never recovering from the losses and tragedy her family endured because of their faith

Antoinette—Isabelle’s childhood rival and later, nemesis; she haunts and challenges Isabelle

Strengths:

• Dramatic portrayal of French persecution of Huguenots
• Vivid setting details
• Well-researched historical background (about Huguenots and Filles du Roi)

Weakness:

In the opening scenes, the high tension of the persecution of Huguenots in La Rochelle is beyond my comfort zone

Content review:

This novel includes violence (including sexual violence) related to persecution and war.

My recommendation:

After the tense early scenes, I found Isabella’s adventures exciting, if sometimes hair-raising. If you favor novels from a past era about heroes persecuted for their beliefs, where survival demands both sacrifice and hope, you’ll enjoy Daughter of the King.

Reader, can you recommend a favorite novel set in France during the Wars of Religion?

The Cost of Conscience: The Courage of Georges Picquart

The Cost of Conscience: The Courage of Georges Picquart

Imagine you discovered evidence that an innocent man was sentenced to life in prison. Would you try to exonerate him if it would cost you your career?

Georges Picquart, the head of France’s spy agency in 1894, faces this dilemma in An Officer and a Spy, Robert Harris’s 2013 historical novel that overwhelmingly remains faithful to the facts of the Dreyfus Affair.

An Officer and a Spy, by Robert Harris, cover image

Alfred Dreyfus, the highest-ranking Jewish officer in the French Army, is convicted of spying for Germany in 1895 and sent to Devil’s Island (a bleak, tiny atoll in the Caribbean).

In 1896, Georges Picquart, the new French Army intelligence head, stumbles across a document proving that Dreyfus is innocent, hence revealing that someone else within the French Army spied for Germany. 

The remainder of the novel recounts Picquart’s struggles to exonerate Dreyfus, the Army’s attempts to silence the story, the roles of numerous characters, and the ultimate resolution of the conflict.

 I loved this book because:

  • I like stories with heroes, especially sweet if they survive their trials
  • Picquart refuses his Army superiors’ demands in spite of the risk to himself
  • Harris’s detailed portrayals of the characters and their motivations
  • Characters’ warts show in Harris’s presentation—no one comes across as perfect
  • Deep, immersive description of French society in that era

Characters:

Georges Picquartnarrator and protagonist, he’s a French Army officer who is promoted to head of the intelligence department after Dreyfus’s conviction.   

Alfred DreyfusJewish Army officer whose performance and grades at the French Military College enabled him to rise higher than any previous soldier of Jewish heritage

General MercierFrench war minister who brought charges against Dreyfus after the discovery that someone in the Army hierarchy had spied for Germany, despite weak evidence

Lucie Dreyfuswife of Alfred Dreyfus, she works doggedly for years to free her husband

Ferdinand Walsin-Esterhazy—a dissolute French Army major suspected of treason (by Picquart)

A number of other French Army officers, including generals, play significant roles in this novel, overwhelmingly in support of the honor of the Army and the conviction of Dreyfus, even if this involves a cover-up of the truth, including sentencing an innocent man to a tortuous life imprisonment.

Strengths:

  • Thorough, detailed account of the entire story
  • Multi-dimensional, complex portrayals of major characters that help explain their decisions, failures, and changes of perspective

Weakness:

The novel’s length, complexity, and repetition of key elements present a challenge to readers

Content review:

This novel contains not only references to romantic liaisons outside of marriage, but depictions of extreme mistreatment and violence.

My recommendation:

I found An Officer and a Spy fascinating, in spite of its length. People in high positions sometimes go to great lengths to preserve their reputations, even if it means innocent people will suffer greatly.  This novel offers the author’s in-depth characterization of Picquart’s thought process and his efforts to remain true to his moral code, in spite of the Army’s intense pressure and shocking treatment of himself as well as Dreyfus.

Reader, can you recommend a true-to-life novel in which the protagonist sacrifices so much to bring justice to an individual?

Risking It All for the Unknown: Julia Hancock’s Journey

Risking It All for the Unknown: Julia Hancock’s Journey

If you could trade a comfortable, predictable future, dictated by your family, for a life of adventures with a famous explorer you hardly knew, would you do it?

In Brook Allen’s recent novel, West of Santillane, teenager Julia Hancock faced those choices in the early 1800s on her family’s Virginia plantation.

West of Santillane, by Brook Allen, cover image

As the author recounts Julia’s choices and their consequences, she immerses readers in the excitement, joys, and sorrows of this era. Julia’s beliefs, perhaps unusual for someone in her position, play a central role and enhance the tension in this story.

 

Major Characters:

Julia Hancockindependent young Virginia woman from a traditional plantation owner’s family; she enjoys literature and marries William Clark

William Clarkmilitary man and explorer who, with Lewis, journeyed across the U.S. to the Pacific Ocean on the expedition President Thomas Jefferson commissioned

Meriwether Lewiscommander of the expedition, a brilliant scientist but unrefined man who never married

 

Harriet (Harri) KennerlyJulia’s cousin and friend; she lacked Julia’s sense of adventure

 

Yorkenslaved man who grew up with and worked for William Clark; Clark’s beliefs about slavery determined the course of York’s life.

 

Chief Sheheke-ShoteMandan Native American leader who assisted Lewis and Clark on their expedition and later met President Jefferson in Washington, D.C.

Yellow Cornwife of Chief Sheheke; while stranded in St. Louis, she and Julia become friends

Pierre Chouteauprominent French-Creole businessman from a St. Louis family who made its fortune from furs and investments; he befriended the Clarks and Lewis

Ramses and Odysseus Phipps—squatters who resented Lewis and Clark’s kind treatment of Chief Sheheke and his family

Nicholas Biddleeditor who helped bring the journals of Lewis and Clark about their expedition to publication

Strengths:

  • Interesting coming of age story combined with moral conflict

  • Vivid portrayal of life, both on a Virginia plantation and in St. Louis in pioneer days

  • Window into Lewis and Clark’s expedition, revealing the physical and emotional cost of the expedition for all those involved

  • Showed the sacrifices made by Native Americans who cooperated with the expedition

Weakness:

The author’s portrayal of Julia Hancockas strongly believing that slavery was wrong and should be ended—is a key part of this novel, yet this may or may not be factual. Historical evidence is lacking, so it may represent the author’s literary license (which is acceptable in historical fiction, but should be noted).

 

Content review:

This novel contains descriptions of violence, mostly as applied to slaves, and a moderate amount of physical intimacy.

 

My Recommendation:

I recommend West of Santillane to readers who, like me, enjoy an exciting story that shows how major historical trends and events—such as slavery and Lewis and Clark’s cross-country expedition—shape the lives of people, from the privileged to the oppressed.

Reader, can you recommend a novel or work of non-fiction about the expedition of William Clark, Meriwether Lewis, or their expedition?

Not Quite as Sung: The Story Behind the Sound of Music

Not Quite as Sung: The Story Behind the Sound of Music

Greetings, Reader Friend!

 

If you’re of a certain age and grew up in the U.S., you doubtless remember the movie, The Sound of Music.

It’s an old story, so why did Maria: A Historical Novel of Maria von Trapp, about the movie’s main character, become a bestseller when it came out in 2024?

Maria: A Novel of Maria von Trapp, by Michelle Moran, cover image

Although it isn’t an exposé, Maria offers readers a more complex, fact-based view of the von Trapp family members than the movie portrayed.

Author Michelle Moran reveals each character’s motivations, while avoiding one-dimensional portrayals as heroes or villains.

For instance, Maria wanted the best for her family, and she possessed great talent and motivation, but these traits sometimes negatively impacted her family.

Major Characters:

Maria—protagonist who tells her life story over the course of the novel

Fran Connelly—Oscar Hammerstein’s secretary; he sends her to learn Maria’s life story and persuade her not to protest the musical’s divergences from the events of her life

Peter—friend and co-worker of Fran

Oscar Hammerstein—lyricist who picks up Maria’s story and (with Richard Rodgers) recreates it as a Broadway musical

Captain Georg von Trapp—widowed father of seven children when Maria meets him

Lorli (Eleonore)—Maria and Georg’s youngest daughter, she’s Maria’s companion in her declining years

Father Franz Wasner—chaplain and researcher of Gregorian chants, conducts the family choir

Lotte Lehmann—famous operatic soprano who stays with the von Trapps and encourages them to tour

Baroness Matilda—housedame; supervisor of the von Trapp house

Princess Yvonne—engaged to the captain before he met Maria

 

Strengths:

  • The author cleverly wove Maria’s story with the production of Rogers and Hammerstein’s Sound of Music, and the lives of those associated with the story.
  • This novel reveals complexities unknown to the public:
  • Hammerstein sacrifices a faithful portrayal of Maria’s life story to create a musical that would succeed in the post-World War II era
  • In addition, Hammerstein fictionalizes his depictions of other members of the von Trapp family to tell a more winsome story

Weakness:

The points of views alternate between Maria and Fran, and at times, readers may find this disorienting.

 

Content review:

The threat of Nazi violence hangs over the story, but nothing occurs on stage.

My recommendation:

Readers like me will enjoy this fascinating novel. Maria expands on the story of The Sound of Music and improves it by setting the record straight in an entertaining way.

Reader, can you recommend a novel or work of non-fiction about the von Trapp family?