Three Generations of Heroines

by CLR Peterson | Sep 23, 2024 | Book review, France, French Resistance, Historical novels, World War II

This month, I’m pleased to offer you a review of a novel I recently enjoyed.

With its title, The Women of Chateau Lafayette, you might expect a biography of Lafayette’s wife, but this novel offers much more.

The Women of Chateau Lafayette, by Stephanie Dray, cover image

This amazing time slip novel draws readers into three distinct eras, separated by generations but united in several ways:

Each takes place in one of history’s darkest hours
Each is set at least partially at Castle Chavaniac, the residence of Gilbert Lafayette, the Frenchman who helped the American colonies win their independence so long ago
Each female protagonist’s efforts culminated in heroism at Chavaniac

Summary of each time period:

(includes protagonists; kept general to avoid spoilers)

Revolutionary era: After helping American colonists win their independence from the British, Gilbert Lafayette returns to France a hero and helps spark the French Revolution, which goes terribly wrong. His family and the French nation suffer grievously. Gilbert’s wife, Adrienne, must navigate between the values of her wealthy noble family and Gilbert’s ideals of democracy, political liberty, and religious freedom. Her heroism will surprise or even shock readers.
In World War I, Beatrice, whose marriage to William “Willie” Astor Chanler, elevated her from humble beginnings, finds her passion in creating the Lafayette Memorial Fund, first supplying care packages for French soldiers in the trenches, and then helping refugee children orphaned by the war. Her husband buys Castle Chavaniac for her, and she manages its transformation into a sanctuary for displaced children and orphans. She is torn between her failed marriage and a new life with a kind Frenchman who loves and supports her.
During World War II, Marthe, an orphan who grew up at Castle Chavaniac, now teaches there. She must come to terms with her identity, as well as deciding how she can live out her ideals with integrity during and after the Nazi occupation of France.

Other major characters:

Maxime Furlaud—a banker and military officer; Beatrice’s French romantic interest

Victor Chapman—Willie’s nephew, close to Beatrice and Willie; an American architecture student who joined the French Foreign Legion

Emily Sloane—Beatrice’s American friend who works with her to gather aid and work at Chavaniac

Baron Amaury de LaGrange—husband of Emily Sloane; interim president of Preventorium at Chavaniac after Fall of France Riom Trial

Anne—daughter of Emily and Amaury, contemporary of Marthe

Yves Travert—small-town policeman who keeps an eye on Chavaniac and Marthe; he must cooperate somewhat with the Gestapo

Madame Pinton—mother of Marthe’s fiancé, she plays an unexpected role

Strengths:

This is a fascinating novel, with its three linked plots, all strong, well-portrayed, and providing windows into life in France in each era.

Weakness:

Three time frames and sets of characters can lead to confusion for readers, who may benefit from taking a few notes as they read.

Content review:

This novel doesn’t shy away from the violence of war, or expressions of the major characters’ sexuality.

My recommendation:

Readers who enjoy historical fiction steeped with romance and values (both personal and societal) will find The Women of Chateau Lafayette a rewarding and thought-provoking read.

Reader, do you have a favorite time slip historical novel?

My writing update:

I continue to sift through the comments of my beta-readers and polish my upcoming novel, Lucia’s Journey.

Escape to Oregon’s Pioneer Days

by CLR Peterson | Aug 23, 2024 | Book review, Historical novels, Medical History, Oregon Territory, Women's Struggles

Greetings, Reading Friend!

I hope you’ve had a chance for a break during this warm season (in the northern hemisphere). I’ve enjoyed time with family and friends in my native Pacific Northwest.

Returning to my Northwest roots, I discovered a novel set in that region, All She Left Behind, and I review it below.

When I’m not reading other authors’ novels, I’m revising Lucia’s Journey, my new novel, based on feedback from my beta-readers. (Thank you so much to each one!). I hope to publish it in the next few months.

My Review of All She Left Behind, by Jane Kirkpatrick

All She Left Behind, by Jane Kirkpatrick, cover image

How could a girl who struggled with reading and spelling, born into a pioneer family settled in the Oregon Territory, become a medical doctor?

Jennie Lichtenthaler’s passion to be a healer seemed an impossible dream, and she received little encouragement to pursue a life beyond the traditional role of wife and mother.

Yet All She Left Behind, a historical novel, tells the surprising, fact-based story of Jennie’s life. Readers may think its twists and turns couldn’t possibly reflect reality, but its skillful author, Jane Kirkpatrick, has crafted this captivating novel using information gleaned from historical documents.

Kirkpatrick shows the obstacles Jennie faced, including:

The attitudes of close family members
Society’s reluctance to allow female physicians.

The author also reveals how dreams delayed were not always dreams destroyed in Jennie’s life.

Characters:

They are both historical and fictional, distinctive, some even memorable.

Because Jennie’s life story includes many characters, I list only those who play major roles in the novel:

Jennie Lichtenthaler—protagonist; young pioneer woman married at 17; her circumstances thwart her ambition to become a physician

Josiah Parrish—Jennie’s second husband, a blacksmith, sheep breeder, and missionary who encourages Jennie’s medical studies and career

Elizabeth Parrish—Josiah’s first wife; Jennie takes care of her in Elizabeth’s declining days

Charles Pickett—Jennie’s first husband, he can’t overcome his addictions to alcohol and drugs

Douglas Pickett—son of Jennie and Charles, he struggles with addictions

Ariyah Cole—Jennie’s fictional best friend, an artist who provides a sounding board and support for Jennie

Priscilla Melvin—a prostitute whose life takes a new turn; Jennie’s encounters with her near the beginning and ending of Jennie’s adult life reveal her character arc.

Callie Charlton—Jennie’s fellow female medical student and colleague

Strengths:

Inspiring story
Well-developed characters
Setting details transport readers into the Oregon Territory and early days of statehood in the last half of the 1800s
This novel reveals the state of the medical profession and the status of women in that era.

Weakness:

The prologue seemed a bit confusing to place in the context of the chapters that follow.

Content review:

This novel discusses struggles with and details of addiction to alcohol, drugs, and sex.

My recommendation:

All She Left Behind will appeal to readers who appreciate a lively plot that Includes historical as well as romantic and inspirational elements. As a native of the Pacific Northwest, I enjoyed the window this novel provided into the history of Oregon in the early days of statehood.

Reader, can you recommend a novel set in the Northwest?

Celebrate with me!

by CLR Peterson | Jul 24, 2024 | Bohemia, Book review, England, France, Reformation

I invite you, Reader, to celebrate with me!

I’m excited to offer my review of the favorite novel I’ve read in 2024! (see below)
My second grandson has arrived in the world, and my husband and I have the opportunity to participate in his family’s life almost daily!
The revisions of my new novel are nearly finished!

I hope you’re finding things to celebrate in this season, too!

The Mercy Seller, by Brenda Rickman Vantrease, cover image

**My Review of The Mercy Seller:**

You may be familiar with Martin Luther’s reform efforts and eventual break from the Roman Church in the 1500s…

But these earlier reformers had less success and paid a terrible price:

John Wycliffe, a cleric who translated the Bible into English in the late 1300s (His followers became known as Lollards)
Jan Hus, a preacher in Prague in the early 1400s who championed Wycliffe’s ideas in Bohemia.

Why?

The Mercy Seller, Brenda Rickman Vantrease’s 2007 novel, immerses readers in the cultures in which Wycliffe and Hus lived (England and Bohemia, respectively). After reading it, I understood in a visceral way why the beliefs and reforms that Wycliffe and Hus proposed were doomed to fail in their times and locations.

Because Anna was raised with the teachings of Jan Hus in Prague, she must flee and undertake a dangerous journey, both physical and metaphorical, to find safety and a new life.

Without a guide, this young woman struggles to know whom to trust. The people she encounters challenge her view of the world, as her perspective challenges theirs.

This compelling story of courage, betrayal, persecution, and character growth also gives readers a window into an era far removed from ours.

Characters:

Some were easy to root for, others easy to hate, some evoked both emotions

Gabriel/VanCleve—title character, an English priest assigned to sell pardons/indulgences; his background and many-faceted career become central to the story
Anna—protagonist who grew up in Prague, raised with Lollard beliefs by her grandfather, Finn; she learns his trade but must flee Prague after religious persecution begins
Finn—copyist of writings of Wycliffe and gospels of the New Testament, fled from England to Prague to escape persecution of Lollards
Abbess Kathryn—leader of the abbey at Saint Martin’s that specializes in copying texts, both sacred and secular
Brother Francis—Gabriel’s spiritual father and mentor
Little Bek—abandoned handicapped boy; Anna mothers him
Sir John Oldcastle, Lord Cobham—member of House of Lords; he and his wife use their wealth in generous ways, among which are supporting the Lollard community and the copying of religious texts into English
Prince Hal (Henry V of England)—friend of Cobham’s during their military years; torn between his need for Archbishop of Canterbury’s blessing of his coronation and his friendship with Sir John Oldcastle
Archbishop Arundel—aged, declining leader of Roman Church in England; determined to root out heresies and heretics from England

Strengths:

Characters—three-dimensional, their arcs reveal clear change; the author shows us their flaws as well as (for some) their heroic qualities
Heroic theme—self-sacrifice for one’s beliefs
Plot—fascinating threads connect the characters, including multiple generations; plot twists that keep readers on edge
Settings—portrayals of the several settings provide telling details to immerse readers

Weakness:

Alternating points of view between characters from scene to scene can confuse readers until they get their bearings.

Content review:

Readers should anticipate a few scenes of physical intimacy, but not of a graphic nature, as well as descriptions of executions in this time period.

My recommendation:

If you enjoy an exciting story of strong-willed individuals whose religious convictions lead them to risk and sacrifice their lives, and whose interactions shape their characters, I highly recommend The Mercy Seller.

Reader, can you recommend novels set in the world of John Wycliffe or Jan Hus?

Read a Terrific Book or Two!

by CLR Peterson | Jun 23, 2024 | Book review, Contagious disease, Historical novels, U.S. History

If you’re a new reader, welcome!

Welcome back to my long-time readers!

I have an invitation for all of you:

Would you like to be an advance reader for my new novel?

Your input can help me make it the best it can be!

If you’re interested, please reply and I’ll send you more information.

Thanks for considering!

Now on to our latest book review:

Why should you read a novel about the Influenza Epidemic of 1918? You’ve probably heard, if not read, about it.

The Orphan Collector, by Ellen Marie Wiseman, cover image

I recently discovered The Orphan Collector, a novel focused on this epidemic, and I could hardly put it down.

Why?

I worried about the characters—would they overcome their many challenges?
Multiple plot threads kept me interested in more than just whether the characters would survive the epidemic

When the influenza epidemic strikes Philadelphia in 1918, Pia, a shy German immigrant in her early teens, struggles to keep her family alive and together.

In the midst of this devastating plague, well-intentioned strangers send her to an orphanage.

She experiences both the highs and lows of human behavior: selfishness, cruelty, bigotry, prejudice, and deception, as well as friendship, kindness, forgiveness, and sacrificial love.

The Orphan Collector takes readers with Pia as she wages a heroic battle for her family’s and personal survival.

Major Characters:

Pia Lange—young protagonist, she must mature and struggle with difficult personal qualities to survive and help her family

Finn—Pia’s Irish neighbor, a kind teen who becomes her loyal friend

Bernice Groves (Nurse Wallis)—Pia’s neighbor whose losses bring out her best and worst qualities as she deals with orphans, grieving parents, and the world

Mother Joe—director of St. Vincent’s Orphan Asylum, where Pia was forced to live; she employs the severe discipline frequent in that era, but also shows wisdom at times

Dr. and Mrs. Hudson—sympathetic couple who employ Pia as their nanny

Max and Ollie—Pia’s twin baby brothers for whom she risks everything

Strengths:

Strong plot
Sympathetic major characters draw readers in
Antagonistic characters are shown as multi-dimensional people whose weaknesses may arise from factors beyond their control.

Weakness:

A situation or two seems a bit contrived.

Content review:

Includes descriptions of the symptoms and after effects of influenza infection that may disturb some readers
Very limited violence
No descriptions of physical intimacy
Some mild profanity

My Recommendation:

If you enjoy an engaging story with heroic yet realistic characters, and you don’t flinch from the realities of an epidemic, The Orphan Collector will be a rewarding read.

Reader, is there a story you love with heroic characters in extreme situations?

Arrivederci/ Until next time,

Colleen

clrpeterson.com

Lucia’s Renaissance: a Novel of 16th-century Italy

By the way, it’s not too late if you’d like to find out more about joining My Renaissance in Venice tour in September, 2025! Just send me a comment if you’d like more information.

Exploring Ancestry and Early America Through ‘Caleb’s Crossing’ + an Invitation

by CLR Peterson | May 23, 2024 | Book review, Historical novels, U.S. History

Review of 'Caleb’s Crossing' by Geraldine Brooks

Why would I read and write about Caleb’s Crossing, a historical novel set on the east coast of seventeenth-century North America, when my primary fiction interest is Renaissance Europe?

Caleb's Crossing, by Geraldine Brooks, cover image

Thanks to recent research discoveries about my family’s ancestors, I learned that one of my 10^th great-grandfathers arrived in America 15 years after the Mayflower landed (in 1620). Although many of this novel’s characters spring from the author’s imagination, her deeply-researched portrayal of the era’s physical, political and religious background helps me understand the context of my ancestors’ lives.

Why should you read this historical novel that came out over a decade ago?

The story is engaging, yet complicated
You’ll find out about living conditions faced by early English settlers
You’ll observe the complex relationships between English settlers and Native Americans
You’ll learn about the beliefs of the Puritans, settlers who dissented from them, and the Native Americans in the region
You’ll get a unique view of the mixed early history of Harvard College (now University)

Author Geraldine Brooks traces two major threads in Caleb’s Crossing:

The impact of English settlers on the Native Americans in the regions where they co-existed.

Brooks writes that Caleb, the title character, was the Native American historical figure who inspired this novel. According to historical records, he and Joel Iacoomis were the first Native Americans to complete their undergraduate degrees at Harvard (in 1665).

In the final pages, Bethia wonders if Caleb would have been better off if she hadn’t accepted his friendship and eventually gone to Harvard.

The life story and choices of Bethia, the young female protagonist.

Early in the story, she writes about her mother’s death in childbirth, but then says “I killed my mother.”

Throughout the novel, the author explores why Bethia believes that statement, as well as the interplay between the transplanted English culture she lived in and her contacts with Native Americans, and how both shaped her beliefs and actions.

Major Characters:

Note: all but Caleb and Joel are fictitious, although some are modeled after historical figures

Caleb—sympathetic male protagonist, member of Wampanoag tribe of Noepe (Martha’s Vineyard) who meets Bethia by chance and befriends her
Bethia Mayfield—female protagonist, she’s the quick-witted daughter of immigrants whose father is a missionary to Native Americans and the minister of the English church in Great Harbor
Makepeace—Bethia’s older brother, less intellectually gifted than she is
Joel Iacoomis—brilliant son of the first Wampanoag convert to Christianity
Samuel Corlett—fellow at Harvard who tutors young scholars; he meets Bethia when she works for his father, Master Corlett, a preparatory school instructor
Anne—young Nipmuc Native American girl, she comes to the preparatory school because of her gift for learning

Strengths:

This novel is extremely well-researched; the characters are memorable, and the plot contains many twists that hold readers’ interest.

Weakness:

A few plot points didn’t seem credible to me, especially as regards Bethia’s openness to Native American culture.

Content review:

This novel contains mentions of off-stage violence and discussions of sexual intimacy.

My Recommendation:

If you’d like to learn more about Native Americans’ interactions with the first English settlers they encountered, or perhaps have an interest in 17^th-century U.S. history, Caleb’s Crossing is an entertaining way to absorb that information, with the caveat that the author used her imagination to create the characters’ personalities and actions.

Reader, can you recommend other novels about colonial North America?

My Update and an Invitation:

I have exciting news and an invitation for readers who’d enjoy a relaxed, curated journey to Venice and the surrounding countryside:

I’ve been invited to share my knowledge of Renaissance Venice during a 7 to 10 day journey in September, 2025. This tour will combine the highlights of Renaissance Venice with time to focus on reflection and personal renaissance during our stay at a comfortable residence in the countryside.

I’m looking forward to sharing my passions for the Renaissance and for writing fiction with interested group members. I hope the journey and our conversations will inspire each guest to pursue their dream, whatever it may be. I’m pleased to partner with Travel Impactful, a unique tour company with values I support.

This will be a small-group tour for 15 to 20 guests. If you’d like more information, click YES button below, insert your name and email address, or submit a comment below.

YES!

Arrivederci/until next time,

Colleen
clrpeterson.com

In the Shadows of Royalty: Labor of Love in the Medici Court

by CLR Peterson | Apr 17, 2024 | Book review, Historical novels, Italy, Renaissance, Renaissance Florence

Do you think a recent novel entitled, Labor of Love, is:

Related to a Shakespeare play
The story of a pregnant woman’s experience giving birth
Something entirely different

In the case of Marguerite Martin Gray’s recent novel, answer #3 is correct.

Labor of Love, by Marguerite Martin Gray, cover image

Summary:

Without further clues, you probably wouldn’t guess this author’s Labor of Love is set at the Pitti Palace, the residence of the Medici family that ruled Florence in the late Renaissance. Martin Gray takes us behind the scenes to reveal much about the Medici family in the weeks before their youngest daughter, Lucrezia, marries Duke Alfonso d’Este. And this is only the background in which Ana and Marco, the young protagonists, attempt to pursue their life’s goals and encounter each other.

The Medici family dominates the lives of many in Florence, including Ana, the family’s impoverished country relative. Not only do the Medicis control Ana’s activities at Pitti Palace, but Duke Cosimo chooses a husband for her (Guido Salviati) without giving her any say in the decision. This creates the novel’s major conflict—the more Ana gets to know Salviati, the more he repulses her, yet she is only a pawn in the Medicis’ political chess game.

Characters:

Ana Geovani—the sympathetic female protagonist, cousin and companion to the Medici daughters. Her passion is working in gardens, communing with God through nature.
Marco Rossi—the male protagonist, he’s a gardener with big plans for design, architecture, and ultimately owning his own land.
Duke Cosimo de’ Medici—ruler of Florence, he’s a wealthy banker and master politician and powerful as a king
Duchess Eleonora de’ Medici—Cosimo’s wife, strict and controlling all matters relating to her family and its position in society
Lucrezia de’ Medici—privileged youngest daughter of Cosimo and Eleonora, Ana’s closest cousin. Her life presents a marked contrast to Ana’s.
Guido Salviati—the villain, a military acquaintance of Duke Cosimo. The duke promises him Ana’s hand in marriage, in an effort to maintain Salviati’s loyalty.
Ernesto and Rosa Arturo—Head gardener at Pitti Palace, and his wife; they befriend Ana, modeling compassion and love

Strengths:

Labor of Love is an engaging story about life in Florence’s Pitti Palace with vivid details about the gardens and plants, descriptions of clothing and foods.

Weakness:

In an era when only priests had access to Bibles, the author didn’t demonstrate clearly how Ana, Rosa, and Ernesto, all lay people, were able to learn so much about religious faith—other than they saw God in nature and attended Mass.

Content review:

This novel definitely qualifies as clean, but it contains references to spousal abuse and allusions to threatened sexual violence

My recommendation:

Labor of Love offers an entertaining way to learn about life in late Italian Renaissance Florence and its ruling family, the Medicis, as well as characters in less fortunate positions in society. Readers who enjoy a faith-based romance will especially appreciate this novel.

Reader, can you recommend other novels about Renaissance Florence?